I look back on my days of supporting NPR, and their oh-so-compassionate presentation of lies, with shame.
The only point I'd pursue more conversation on is with regard to "balance". I believe that balance is essential - but that we aren't able (or willing) to zoom out enough to recognize that it's out of our human ability to create, or restore. We can, as you show here, resist and expose the lies. And Thank God that he instilled in His creation the power to heal.
The principal of balance is important in the physical world, as can be seen in the balance between protons and electrons in atoms, and the necessary balance between predator and prey species. The problem springs from theological differences i.e., the earth is God-Gaia, and therefore must not be tampered with, versus the earth is the creation of God, given to humans for our proper use, not misuse i.e., polluting it, or destroying it with nuclear weapons.
Case in point, there is a fight brewing in north central California, Federal Energy Regulatory Commission Project 77, currently owned by those wonders stewards of electric generation and transmission and distribution Pacific Gas and Electric are surrendering the license. They and the moonbats are about to set on the effort to removal two dams and on hydroelectric project, change the distribution of the water so they can recover salmon populations which are in decline…sure. People there need support. Just google Potter Valley dam removal and stand by for the usual list of suspects to rear their ugly dystopian heads. Aided and abetted by California’s ruling class (movie moguls, vineyard owners, tech giants, professors at Cal Berkeley ya know the ones who know everything and yet know nothing.) It is mind blowing. We can only hope as the community galvanize to fight the dam removal and the destruction of their way of life, only on a scale much larger than here to fore in theses matters, that they can prevail. Talk about an axis evil, PG&E, state government and the federal representatives all salivating at the prospective of an entire community being destroyed. One can only guess the fire that PG&E’s lousy line maintenance caused with the Paradise Fires was just a precursor to where this bunch are headed. Empty out San Francisco minus District 3, ya know Nob Hill and North Beach need to saved for the virtuous, decent and kind. The unshaven and unwashed well they can float out past the Golden Gate Bridge. Crazy time has to stop at some point.
I have a rancher friend about to lose her family’s fourth gen ranch because of those dams. Heartbreaking. She has to sleep with the windows open because introduced wolves kill their cattle - it is so cruel.
The only way to handle this maddness is fight back. In the case of the Potter Valley dam they need to galvanize, petition for intervenor status in the surrender of the license process and get the Sec’s of Interior, agriculture and energy on the case. In addition to the water the dams hold back and are used by the community there is a 9 megawatt hydroelectric generation unit that has been allowed to fall out of service. That unit properly run could provide true renewable energy on a local distribution level. Of course hydro is not considered renewable in the USA..on and on it goes. Keep up your fight. Improvise, adapt and overcome.
This is one of the clearest pieces I’ve read in years. You trace an idea back to its roots and show how “science” was twisted into ideology and then weaponized for control.
I grew up when environmental stewardship meant balance and responsibility, not punishment. What you describe, the hijacking of conservation by elites with no skin in the game, explains the decline of rural life and the economic paralysis across the West. You can’t hollow out a working landscape and expect a healthy society to survive.
“Culture is far more fragile than nature.” That line hit me. The land heals quickly when left alone, but once a way of life, a farm, a family trade, a small-town economy, is erased, it rarely comes back.
Thank you for tracing the rot to its philosophical and political origins. This isn’t just about elk or frogs. It’s about self-determination. Fix the science, and you start fixing the world.
Excellent article, I’m glad you visited our state and saw firsthand the quality of rural communities. Another nefarious group to research is the American Prairie Reserve. They are heavily funded by the usual suspects and are buying up family farms and ranches in an effort to create “one of the largest nature reserves in the US.” Once productive ag land is being idled and of course they don’t manage the weeds or anything so their holdings become weed infested wastelands. The invasive weeds then infest neighboring properties requiring constant herbicide use which is then decried by the usual suspects.
I have found many of these people that want to control the rural areas are city folk who never ventured beyond the edge of their metropolis. Or if they do, it's always to another similar cityscape. Their idea of "rural living" is a trailer with out-buildings., which is what they would expect to see if they do make a rural excursion.
I recall the first time I had friends visit me from where I used to live. They made their way to my house and said, "Do you have electricity here?" before they stepped inside.
I am a thankfully retired former professional forester on Vancouver Island who has witnessed and fought in futility these pathologies masquerading as science. Conservation Biology (more like theocracy) is the perversion of the scientific method that need only conjure an hypothesis and rather than attempt to test and disprove it (that's too mundane, time consuming, and laboratory-oriented) instead, reinforce it and move directly to political action to "mitigate" in a climate of hysterical urgency. That's the now dominant institutional paradigm and now twinned with the nihilism of cultural Marxism in the degraded humanities faculties.
Still a practicing RPF in the Cariboo...the climate based seed transfer, assisted migration, climate models, and carbon bumph are enough to drive me up the wall. It's all about money, and not much else, really. I take comfort in knowing that nature will sort out our mess eventually....
Yes, between the green theocracy and cultural Marxism (racialized access to Crown timber), Alberta, on a productive land-base capacity of less than half of BC's, now harvests more timber than BC.
One of my very favorite movies is The Biggest Little Farm. The farm was an abandoned wasteland before human beings took it over and created a bower of productive beauty, gradually discovering the balance of nature itself in controlling pests. It took 8 years to bring the land to full productivity.
There is a reason that God told humans to have dominion over the earth and subdue it.
Thank you for your bravery and integrity to report on the issues you tackle. The more awareness we have the better we can educate ourselves and your future generations.
We need to fix the educational system as well. Christopher F. Rufo, at rufo@substack.com, is trying to tackle that area.
I think is we all join together we can win this war over the odds stacked against us for so long.
There are others who are fighting the good fight. I support like-minded people I encounter and encourage others to do so and join those fighting for our freedoms.
100%. I learned so much about the historical/philosophical beginnings of the thought processes that led to the fake extinction numbers and how humanity’s relationship with the land became corrupted. And so much more! It is a useful piece for those who are trying to work against the media-metastasized ‘climate change’ brainwash. Thanks to EN.
I grew up in Sudbury ontario, which when I was young was often blanketed with sulfur dioxide from the smelters. The trees were stunted and the forests that had once been there were gone and the soil washed away. 50 years later with changes in technology and production, the area is fast recovering and the past ugliness is being forgotten.
I lived for 50 years in Central Alberta farming country and I've watched the landscape recover during that time. Only 30 years before I moved there, the soil had drifted to the point where buried fences to the top of the posts. These days you wouldn't know that happened.
Back in the 70s, 50% summerfallow was the rule for weed control and several blinding dust storms were to be expected each summer. The use of advanced methods and continuous cropping (which has its critics) has vastly improved production and the environment.
I spend much of my summers sailing out of Salt Spring, going as far as around Vancouver Island, and I visit many remote places that have been industrial and/or logging sites in the past but appear to be pristine now.
I also spend much of my time in the Sea of Cortez, which at one time was seriously damaged by human activity but currently one would never know For the most part. This is, admittedly, due to the efforts of environmentalists to limit commercial activity and some of the original species have not recovered, yet, at least.
Nature has a way of recovering itself quite quickly. That is not to say that we need not be cognizant of harms but that it's easy for us to forget that much North America was scoured by glaciers not too long ago and what we considere to be the proper state of things is just part of a progression.
In spite of the human desire to be in control and to know the future, there are too many unknowables for us to try to manage anything but what's in front of us right now.
One meteor hit, a worldwide volcanic contagion, a major sun event, shifting of the Earth's magnetic field, and many other unpredictable events are likely to interrupt the progession predicted by the Climate Change cartel. They know that but there's no money in talking about it.
Historically in many if not most cultures, human sacrifice was considered, without proof, necessary to control nature to be more beneficent to humans. and although that has largely gone out of style, we are now sacrificing humanity, again on faith, not proof.
The absurdity of biodiversity calculations and policy is that variety is preferred over benefit or resilience. For example, in the UK farmers are being told in jurisdictions pushing the biodiversity agreement that a proliferation of weeds in their crops is good for biodiversity, as is planting multiple crops in one field, and the more insects that eat their crops must be tolerated because more diversity = better in this calculus. It doesn't matter if the diversity is beneficial because it's diversity for the sake of diversity; if it doesn't work, and crop yields are down, then it's the farmer's fault (he's just not doing it right). Perhaps the same attitude is behind current multiculturalism...🤔
I am so relieved to read your article, a neighbor mentioned you by chance as I was walking by, and it is wonderful to read! I had long ago studied ecology and these so called nature writers you mention, and ecopsychology was a very seductive field. But something in me knew in my heart and my own experience it was shaming to the soul, the individual.
And to the earth..
When Jane Goodalll died i saw how she'd been captured and controlled like a trained monkey, sad.
And I could not worship her as many did. Anyway thanks so very much Elizabeth!
I felt a bit weird saying that about Jane, as I'd been inspired by her as a child. It was confusing. I watched some older interviews from the 80s in which she said funny surprising things and her body and face were quite expressive. Later I met her in the 90s and she'd lost some spark, was promoting her Roots and Shoots. I would rather have felt some wildness and playfulness but anyway all very interesting to learn and discern, without feeling bad about it.
This is a MUCH NEEDED and BRILLIANT connecting the dots of the sham of environmentalism, species extinction AND bad science. Thank-you for pointing me in the direction of Alston Chase, and big kudos to you for driving to Montana.....as in what REAL journalism is about. Also, a tip of the hat to Patrick Watson who has been yelling from the rooftops for decades that "carbon dioxide is the most important nutrient on earth and without this we would be a dead planet"......full stop.
Science relies on evidence gathered from the natural world through observation and experimentation, formulating hypothesis, designing experiments, analyzing data and then, and only then, drawing conclusions.....NOT a claim or assumption, which are personal opinions and beliefs. Otherwise you have to scrap whatever claim and begin anew. WE have been led astray for so long it will take a very long common sense investigation, inquiry and actual interest to turn this ship around. This post is one of those reveals at the crux of that investigation and empowers us to "create or restore" what is NOT lost but needs fearlessly unveiling, re-examining and clarifying anew.
I thank you for a great history lesson. The notion that Rachel Carson lied about everything is mind-boggling.
As to the Point Reyes elk. I lived in the same county (Marin) for 40 years and kept up with the local news. I do not know why the Point Reyes peninsula was made a national seashore, but many wrongs have resulted. Forcing the ranchers off the land is a big wrong. Importing elk from somewhere else was another wrong. Point Reyes might have had elk before the Whites arrived about 1850 (with the gold rush), but it was a different species. The current elk herd has reproduced significantly, especially in the face of zero predators. Some years their herd growth is considered a problem needing solution. Would you believe elk birth control is discussed in the local newspaper? The herd interferes with the remaining ranchers and the tourists in their cars.
The ranchers contribute quality milk to the local consumers. The area is attracting attention for the quality of its cheesemaking. We consumers enjoy quality foods and the ranching families - many Hispanic - enrich the local communities.
It is usually the “know nothings” who think they know everything. Their ideas are encased in tunnel vision, bend the truth vernacular, that make them pompous.
I look back on my days of supporting NPR, and their oh-so-compassionate presentation of lies, with shame.
The only point I'd pursue more conversation on is with regard to "balance". I believe that balance is essential - but that we aren't able (or willing) to zoom out enough to recognize that it's out of our human ability to create, or restore. We can, as you show here, resist and expose the lies. And Thank God that he instilled in His creation the power to heal.
The ultimate means of reestablishing the natural "balance" is the extirpation of species Homo sapiens. We are the problem dontcha c?
Balance is a myth at best and implies stillness when all matter is constantly moving and changing
The principal of balance is important in the physical world, as can be seen in the balance between protons and electrons in atoms, and the necessary balance between predator and prey species. The problem springs from theological differences i.e., the earth is God-Gaia, and therefore must not be tampered with, versus the earth is the creation of God, given to humans for our proper use, not misuse i.e., polluting it, or destroying it with nuclear weapons.
We have different definitions. I agree on the flux, the change. It's a constant dance of re-orientation - I call that "balance".
I accept that. In my ears ‘balance’ has taken on a menacing censoriousness. But I am a bit paranoid
I know what you mean!!
Case in point, there is a fight brewing in north central California, Federal Energy Regulatory Commission Project 77, currently owned by those wonders stewards of electric generation and transmission and distribution Pacific Gas and Electric are surrendering the license. They and the moonbats are about to set on the effort to removal two dams and on hydroelectric project, change the distribution of the water so they can recover salmon populations which are in decline…sure. People there need support. Just google Potter Valley dam removal and stand by for the usual list of suspects to rear their ugly dystopian heads. Aided and abetted by California’s ruling class (movie moguls, vineyard owners, tech giants, professors at Cal Berkeley ya know the ones who know everything and yet know nothing.) It is mind blowing. We can only hope as the community galvanize to fight the dam removal and the destruction of their way of life, only on a scale much larger than here to fore in theses matters, that they can prevail. Talk about an axis evil, PG&E, state government and the federal representatives all salivating at the prospective of an entire community being destroyed. One can only guess the fire that PG&E’s lousy line maintenance caused with the Paradise Fires was just a precursor to where this bunch are headed. Empty out San Francisco minus District 3, ya know Nob Hill and North Beach need to saved for the virtuous, decent and kind. The unshaven and unwashed well they can float out past the Golden Gate Bridge. Crazy time has to stop at some point.
I have a rancher friend about to lose her family’s fourth gen ranch because of those dams. Heartbreaking. She has to sleep with the windows open because introduced wolves kill their cattle - it is so cruel.
The only way to handle this maddness is fight back. In the case of the Potter Valley dam they need to galvanize, petition for intervenor status in the surrender of the license process and get the Sec’s of Interior, agriculture and energy on the case. In addition to the water the dams hold back and are used by the community there is a 9 megawatt hydroelectric generation unit that has been allowed to fall out of service. That unit properly run could provide true renewable energy on a local distribution level. Of course hydro is not considered renewable in the USA..on and on it goes. Keep up your fight. Improvise, adapt and overcome.
More planned destruction of California!
True!
This is one of the clearest pieces I’ve read in years. You trace an idea back to its roots and show how “science” was twisted into ideology and then weaponized for control.
I grew up when environmental stewardship meant balance and responsibility, not punishment. What you describe, the hijacking of conservation by elites with no skin in the game, explains the decline of rural life and the economic paralysis across the West. You can’t hollow out a working landscape and expect a healthy society to survive.
“Culture is far more fragile than nature.” That line hit me. The land heals quickly when left alone, but once a way of life, a farm, a family trade, a small-town economy, is erased, it rarely comes back.
Thank you for tracing the rot to its philosophical and political origins. This isn’t just about elk or frogs. It’s about self-determination. Fix the science, and you start fixing the world.
Excellent article, I’m glad you visited our state and saw firsthand the quality of rural communities. Another nefarious group to research is the American Prairie Reserve. They are heavily funded by the usual suspects and are buying up family farms and ranches in an effort to create “one of the largest nature reserves in the US.” Once productive ag land is being idled and of course they don’t manage the weeds or anything so their holdings become weed infested wastelands. The invasive weeds then infest neighboring properties requiring constant herbicide use which is then decried by the usual suspects.
That sounds like a great example of something Eluzabwrhvsaid. Tge nice boys and girls from sy urban don't work hard enough to keep the places up.
I have found many of these people that want to control the rural areas are city folk who never ventured beyond the edge of their metropolis. Or if they do, it's always to another similar cityscape. Their idea of "rural living" is a trailer with out-buildings., which is what they would expect to see if they do make a rural excursion.
I recall the first time I had friends visit me from where I used to live. They made their way to my house and said, "Do you have electricity here?" before they stepped inside.
I am a thankfully retired former professional forester on Vancouver Island who has witnessed and fought in futility these pathologies masquerading as science. Conservation Biology (more like theocracy) is the perversion of the scientific method that need only conjure an hypothesis and rather than attempt to test and disprove it (that's too mundane, time consuming, and laboratory-oriented) instead, reinforce it and move directly to political action to "mitigate" in a climate of hysterical urgency. That's the now dominant institutional paradigm and now twinned with the nihilism of cultural Marxism in the degraded humanities faculties.
Still a practicing RPF in the Cariboo...the climate based seed transfer, assisted migration, climate models, and carbon bumph are enough to drive me up the wall. It's all about money, and not much else, really. I take comfort in knowing that nature will sort out our mess eventually....
Yes, between the green theocracy and cultural Marxism (racialized access to Crown timber), Alberta, on a productive land-base capacity of less than half of BC's, now harvests more timber than BC.
Sadly, most especially in BC where I lived for 30 years and loved it.
Wonderful article.
One of my very favorite movies is The Biggest Little Farm. The farm was an abandoned wasteland before human beings took it over and created a bower of productive beauty, gradually discovering the balance of nature itself in controlling pests. It took 8 years to bring the land to full productivity.
There is a reason that God told humans to have dominion over the earth and subdue it.
Thank you for your bravery and integrity to report on the issues you tackle. The more awareness we have the better we can educate ourselves and your future generations.
We need to fix the educational system as well. Christopher F. Rufo, at rufo@substack.com, is trying to tackle that area.
I think is we all join together we can win this war over the odds stacked against us for so long.
There are others who are fighting the good fight. I support like-minded people I encounter and encourage others to do so and join those fighting for our freedoms.
Thank you again for your outstanding reporting.
That link takes us to Christopher Rufo’s email. I’ll have to find his substack. Thanks.
100%. I learned so much about the historical/philosophical beginnings of the thought processes that led to the fake extinction numbers and how humanity’s relationship with the land became corrupted. And so much more! It is a useful piece for those who are trying to work against the media-metastasized ‘climate change’ brainwash. Thanks to EN.
We are led by malicious fools. What a disgrace. Shame on us.
"We are governed, our minds are molded, our tastes formed, and our ideas suggested largely by men we have never heard of....." Edward Bernays.
.......and they want to keep it that way.
Stan in TN
I grew up in Sudbury ontario, which when I was young was often blanketed with sulfur dioxide from the smelters. The trees were stunted and the forests that had once been there were gone and the soil washed away. 50 years later with changes in technology and production, the area is fast recovering and the past ugliness is being forgotten.
I lived for 50 years in Central Alberta farming country and I've watched the landscape recover during that time. Only 30 years before I moved there, the soil had drifted to the point where buried fences to the top of the posts. These days you wouldn't know that happened.
Back in the 70s, 50% summerfallow was the rule for weed control and several blinding dust storms were to be expected each summer. The use of advanced methods and continuous cropping (which has its critics) has vastly improved production and the environment.
I spend much of my summers sailing out of Salt Spring, going as far as around Vancouver Island, and I visit many remote places that have been industrial and/or logging sites in the past but appear to be pristine now.
I also spend much of my time in the Sea of Cortez, which at one time was seriously damaged by human activity but currently one would never know For the most part. This is, admittedly, due to the efforts of environmentalists to limit commercial activity and some of the original species have not recovered, yet, at least.
Nature has a way of recovering itself quite quickly. That is not to say that we need not be cognizant of harms but that it's easy for us to forget that much North America was scoured by glaciers not too long ago and what we considere to be the proper state of things is just part of a progression.
In spite of the human desire to be in control and to know the future, there are too many unknowables for us to try to manage anything but what's in front of us right now.
One meteor hit, a worldwide volcanic contagion, a major sun event, shifting of the Earth's magnetic field, and many other unpredictable events are likely to interrupt the progession predicted by the Climate Change cartel. They know that but there's no money in talking about it.
Historically in many if not most cultures, human sacrifice was considered, without proof, necessary to control nature to be more beneficent to humans. and although that has largely gone out of style, we are now sacrificing humanity, again on faith, not proof.
Exactly
Well said!
The absurdity of biodiversity calculations and policy is that variety is preferred over benefit or resilience. For example, in the UK farmers are being told in jurisdictions pushing the biodiversity agreement that a proliferation of weeds in their crops is good for biodiversity, as is planting multiple crops in one field, and the more insects that eat their crops must be tolerated because more diversity = better in this calculus. It doesn't matter if the diversity is beneficial because it's diversity for the sake of diversity; if it doesn't work, and crop yields are down, then it's the farmer's fault (he's just not doing it right). Perhaps the same attitude is behind current multiculturalism...🤔
Near the end of the article, I read this:
"Fix this, and fix the world.
Dig this nonsense out of legislation and regulation and within a decade a new Golden Age.
Bible."
I think that the article was worth my time, and some of my money, too!
And I admit, I like my Bible!
But just the word "Bible" alone has got to be a typo. A fuller expansion of what was meant would be welcomed!
I am so relieved to read your article, a neighbor mentioned you by chance as I was walking by, and it is wonderful to read! I had long ago studied ecology and these so called nature writers you mention, and ecopsychology was a very seductive field. But something in me knew in my heart and my own experience it was shaming to the soul, the individual.
And to the earth..
When Jane Goodalll died i saw how she'd been captured and controlled like a trained monkey, sad.
And I could not worship her as many did. Anyway thanks so very much Elizabeth!
I totally agree on all your points, Pamela.
Thanks, Marsha,
I felt a bit weird saying that about Jane, as I'd been inspired by her as a child. It was confusing. I watched some older interviews from the 80s in which she said funny surprising things and her body and face were quite expressive. Later I met her in the 90s and she'd lost some spark, was promoting her Roots and Shoots. I would rather have felt some wildness and playfulness but anyway all very interesting to learn and discern, without feeling bad about it.
This is a MUCH NEEDED and BRILLIANT connecting the dots of the sham of environmentalism, species extinction AND bad science. Thank-you for pointing me in the direction of Alston Chase, and big kudos to you for driving to Montana.....as in what REAL journalism is about. Also, a tip of the hat to Patrick Watson who has been yelling from the rooftops for decades that "carbon dioxide is the most important nutrient on earth and without this we would be a dead planet"......full stop.
Science relies on evidence gathered from the natural world through observation and experimentation, formulating hypothesis, designing experiments, analyzing data and then, and only then, drawing conclusions.....NOT a claim or assumption, which are personal opinions and beliefs. Otherwise you have to scrap whatever claim and begin anew. WE have been led astray for so long it will take a very long common sense investigation, inquiry and actual interest to turn this ship around. This post is one of those reveals at the crux of that investigation and empowers us to "create or restore" what is NOT lost but needs fearlessly unveiling, re-examining and clarifying anew.
Many thank-you's Elizabeth.
I thank you for a great history lesson. The notion that Rachel Carson lied about everything is mind-boggling.
As to the Point Reyes elk. I lived in the same county (Marin) for 40 years and kept up with the local news. I do not know why the Point Reyes peninsula was made a national seashore, but many wrongs have resulted. Forcing the ranchers off the land is a big wrong. Importing elk from somewhere else was another wrong. Point Reyes might have had elk before the Whites arrived about 1850 (with the gold rush), but it was a different species. The current elk herd has reproduced significantly, especially in the face of zero predators. Some years their herd growth is considered a problem needing solution. Would you believe elk birth control is discussed in the local newspaper? The herd interferes with the remaining ranchers and the tourists in their cars.
The ranchers contribute quality milk to the local consumers. The area is attracting attention for the quality of its cheesemaking. We consumers enjoy quality foods and the ranching families - many Hispanic - enrich the local communities.
I will never forgive the Nature Conservancy.
It is usually the “know nothings” who think they know everything. Their ideas are encased in tunnel vision, bend the truth vernacular, that make them pompous.
Arrogance is usually a compensation for, and in direct proportion to, ignorance.